» Делимся результатами тестов винчестеров программой Drive!

igcomp
IDE c SCSI я не сравнивал. У меня просто 2 WD IDE и 1 IBM SCSI.

Test 1
*************************************************
Test environment information

* Running under: Windows NT 5.1 Build 2600, Service Pack 1
* CPU Type: x86 Family 6 Model 8 Stepping 10, 1002 MHz
* Memory: 383 MB (7% free)
* Swap: 602 MB (3% free)

Drive! 1.0.0 Benchmark Results

* Hard Disk: MAXTOR 4K040H2
* Attached to: Adapter
* Using driver: atapi
* Size: 38177 MBytes
* Geometry:
o Current: 4867 Cylinders, 255 Heads, 63 Sectors
o Default: Unknown


* Average Linear Read Speed: 26,3 Mb/sec
* Min. Linear Read Speed: 15,7 Mb/sec
* Max. Linear Read Speed: 32,1 Mb/sec

* Average Access Time: 16,3 ms
* Max. Cache Read Speed: 83,5 Mb/sec

* Disk Speed Index: 162
***************************************************************
Test 2
****************************************************************
Test environment information

* Running under: Windows NT 5.1 Build 2600, Service Pack 1
* CPU Type: x86 Family 6 Model 8 Stepping 10, 1002 MHz
* Memory: 383 MB (7% free)
* Swap: 602 MB (1% free)

Drive! 1.0.0 Benchmark Results

* Hard Disk: MAXTOR 4K040H2
* Attached to: Adapter
* Using driver: atapi
* Size: 38177 MBytes
* Geometry:
o Current: 4867 Cylinders, 255 Heads, 63 Sectors
o Default: Unknown


* Average Linear Read Speed: 26,7 Mb/sec
* Min. Linear Read Speed: 17,4 Mb/sec
* Max. Linear Read Speed: 33,5 Mb/sec

* Average Access Time: 17,1 ms
* Max. Cache Read Speed: 84,9 Mb/sec

* Disk Speed Index: 157

Ребят, и не надоело Вам тесты гонять - неужели ченить изменится;)
Вот я реально из этого топика никакой реальной инфы не поднял - просто время потерял - а время деньги... - тока не ночью канешна - щас халява

Running under: Windows NT 5.1 Build 2600, Service Pack 1, v.1081
CPU Type: x86 Family 15 Model 2 Stepping 7, 2016 MHz
Memory: 255 MB (8% free)
Swap: 734 MB (4% free)

Drive! 1.0.0 Benchmark Results

Hard Disk: ST360012A
 Attached to: Adapter
 Using driver: atapi.sys
Size: 57239 MBytes
Geometry:
 Current: 7297 Cylinders, 255 Heads, 63 Sectors
 Default: Unknown

Average Linear Read Speed: 34,7 Mb/sec
Min. Linear Read Speed: 7,4 Mb/sec
Max. Linear Read Speed: 46,7 Mb/sec

Average Access Time: 14,6 ms

Max. Cache Read Speed: 98,0 Mb/sec

Disk Speed Index: 237

Добавлено
kollegin
"Ребят, и не надоело Вам тесты гонять - неужели ченить изменится;)
Вот я реально из этого топика никакой реальной инфы не поднял - просто время потерял - а время деньги..."

Не согласен, здесь сводится ценная информация, которая пригодится при выборе нового винта!

тест №1
Running under: Windows NT 5.0 Build 2195, Service Pack 3
CPU Type: x86 Family 6 Model 6 Stepping 2, 1666 MHz
Memory: 735 MB (3% free)
Swap: 1070 MB (2% free)

Hard Disk: ST360021A
Attached to: Adapter
Using driver: atapi.sys
Size: 57239 MBytes
Geometry:
Current: 7297 Cylinders, 255 Heads, 63 Sectors
Default: Unknown

Average Linear Read Speed: 32.9 Mb/sec
Min. Linear Read Speed: 8.8 Mb/sec
Max. Linear Read Speed: 42.3 Mb/sec

Average Access Time: 15.2 ms

Max. Cache Read Speed: 64.6 Mb/sec

Disk Speed Index: 217

---

тест № 2 (все вырублено кроме оперы и винкома и скуельагента)

Running under: Windows NT 5.0 Build 2195, Service Pack 3
CPU Type: x86 Family 6 Model 6 Stepping 2, 1666 MHz
Memory: 735 MB (5% free)
Swap: 1070 MB (0% free)

Hard Disk: ST360021A
Attached to: Adapter
Using driver: atapi.sys
Size: 57239 MBytes
Geometry:
Current: 7297 Cylinders, 255 Heads, 63 Sectors
Default: Unknown

Average Linear Read Speed: 35.3 Mb/sec
Min. Linear Read Speed: 23.6 Mb/sec
Max. Linear Read Speed: 42.3 Mb/sec

Average Access Time: 14.9 ms

Max. Cache Read Speed: 64.3 Mb/sec

Disk Speed Index: 238

А ВАМ слабо???


Running under: Windows NT 5.0 Build 2195, Service Pack 3
CPU Type: x86 Family 6 Model 11 Stepping 1, 1128 MHz
Memory: 511 MB (5% free)
Swap: 579 MB (7% free)

Results

Hard Disk: IBM-ESXSST318305LC !#B244
Attached to: Adapter
Using driver: adpu160m.sys
Size: 17351 MBytes
Geometry:
Current: 2212 Cylinders, 255 Heads, 63 Sectors
Default: Unknown

Average Linear Read Speed: 44,6 Mb/sec
Min. Linear Read Speed: 28,6 Mb/sec
Max. Linear Read Speed: 57,4 Mb/sec

Average Access Time: 8,1 ms

Max. Cache Read Speed: 132,1 Mb/sec

Disk Speed Index: 549

Running under: Windows NT 5.1 Build 2600, Service Pack 1

CPU Type: x86 Family 6 Model 8 Stepping 3, 797 MHz

Memory: 511 MB (2% free)

Swap: 782 MB (2% free)

Drive! 1.0.0 Benchmark Results
Hard Disk: SAMSUNG SV4002H

Attached to: Adapter

Using driver: atapi

Size: 38201 MBytes

Geometry:

Current: 4870 Cylinders, 255 Heads, 63 Sectors

Default: Unknown



Average Linear Read Speed: 24,0 Mb/sec

Min. Linear Read Speed: 14,9 Mb/sec

Max. Linear Read Speed: 32,1 Mb/sec


Average Access Time: 15,3 ms

Max. Cache Read Speed: 34,3 Mb/sec


Disk Speed Index: 157

Running under: Windows NT 5.1 Build 2600, Service Pack 1
CPU Type: x86 Family 6 Model 4 Stepping 4, 1286 MHz
Memory: 511 MB (1% free)
Swap: 766 MB (1% free)
ДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДЭDrive! 1.0.0 Benchmark ResultsЮДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДД
Hard DiskIBM) IC35L040AVER07-0
Attached to: Adapter
Using driver: atapi.sys
Size: 39260 MBytes
Geometry:
Current: 5005 Cylinders, 255 Heads, 63 Sectors
Default: Unknown

Average Linear Read Speed: 29,1 Mb/sec
Min. Linear Read Speed: 17,1 Mb/sec
Max. Linear Read Speed: 41,0 Mb/sec
Average Access Time: 21,7 ms
Max. Cache Read Speed: 102,4 Mb/sec
Disk Speed Index: 139

Вы мне вот что скажите это нормально для этого винта?
И есчо так вопрос чем отличаеться шлейф U-ATA 66(80 жил) от U-ATA 100(80 жил)?

ДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДЭTest environment informationЮДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДД

ю Running under: Windows NT 5.1 Build 2600, Service Pack 1
ю CPU Type: x86 Family 6 Model 8 Stepping 10, 952 MHz
ю Memory: 255 MB (14% free)
ю Swap: 634 MB (6% free)

ДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДЭDrive! 1.0.0 Benchmark ResultsЮДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДДД

ю Hard Disk: IC35L040AVVA07-0 VA2O
 Attached to: HighPoint HPT3xx ATA RAID Controller
 Using driver: hpt3xx.sys
ю Size: 39260 MBytes
ю Geometry:
 Current: 5005 Cylinders, 255 Heads, 63 Sectors
 Default: Unknown

ю Average Linear Read Speed: 34,4 Mb/sec
ю Min. Linear Read Speed: 8,3 Mb/sec
ю Max. Linear Read Speed: 47,0 Mb/sec

ю Average Access Time: 12,5 ms

ю Max. Cache Read Speed: 91,0 Mb/sec

ю Disk Speed Index: 275

SunanG

Цитата:

Вы мне вот что скажите это нормально для этого винта?

Нормально, хотя для IBM'ки, мог быть чуть-чуть побыстрее.

Цитата:

И есчо так вопрос чем отличаеться шлейф U-ATA 66(80 жил) от U-ATA 100(80 жил)?

Ничем.

* Running under: Windows NT 5.1 Build 2600, Service Pack 1
* CPU Type: x86 Family 6 Model 8 Stepping 3, 791 MHz (Celeron-633 @ 791MHz)
* Memory: 383 MB (9% free)
* Swap: 540 MB (0% free)

* Hard Disk: ST380021A (UDMA-100 @ UDMA-33)
 Attached to: Adapter
 Using driver: atapi.sys
* Size: 76316 MBytes
* Geometry:
 Current: 9729 Cylinders, 255 Heads, 63 Sectors
 Default: Unknown

* Average Linear Read Speed: 16,3 Mb/sec
* Min. Linear Read Speed: 14,1 Mb/sec
* Max. Linear Read Speed: 22,9 Mb/sec
* Average Access Time: 14,9 ms
* Max. Cache Read Speed: 29,5 Mb/sec
* Disk Speed Index: 110

Running under: Windows NT 5.1 Build 2600, Service Pack 1
CPU Type: x86 Family 6 Model 6 Stepping 2, 1343 MHz
Memory: 255 MB (13% free)
Swap: 618 MB (2% free)

Hard Disk: IC35L040AVVA07-0
 Attached to: Adapter
 Using driver: atapi.sys
Size: 39260 MBytes
Geometry:
 Current: 5005 Cylinders, 255 Heads, 63 Sectors
 Default: Unknown

Average Linear Read Speed: 35,5 Mb/sec
Min. Linear Read Speed: 21,1 Mb/sec
Max. Linear Read Speed: 47,3 Mb/sec

Average Access Time: 12,2 ms

Max. Cache Read Speed: 102,4 Mb/sec

Disk Speed Index: 291

Yakasama
А ВАМ слабо???
Чё самый умный? Выдал тест скази винта и радуется поуши...

Подниму темку

Test environment information

Running under: Windows NT 5.1 Build 2600, Service Pack 2, v.1204
CPU Type: x86 Family 15 Model 2 Stepping 4, 2405 MHz
Memory: 511 MB (0% free)
Swap: 1250 MB (2% free)

Drive! 1.0.0 Benchmark Results

Hard Disk: Maxtor 6Y080L0
Attached to: Adapter
Using driver: atapi.sys
Size: 78159 MBytes
Geometry:
Current: 9964 Cylinders, 255 Heads, 63 Sectors
Default: Unknown

Average Linear Read Speed: 40,8 Mb/sec
Min. Linear Read Speed: 20,6 Mb/sec
Max. Linear Read Speed: 51,5 Mb/sec

Average Access Time: 13,3 ms

Max. Cache Read Speed: 98,6 Mb/sec

Disk Speed Index: 308

По-моему весьма достойный результат!

___________________________________________

Drive! 1.0.0 Benchmark Results

Hard Disk: ST340810A
Attached to: Adapter
Using driver: atapi.sys
Size: 38162 MBytes
Geometry:
Current: 4865 Cylinders, 255 Heads, 63 Sectors
Default: Unknown

Average Linear Read Speed: 23,7 Mb/sec
Min. Linear Read Speed: 12,0 Mb/sec
Max. Linear Read Speed: 28,6 Mb/sec

Average Access Time: 21,3 ms нехило

Max. Cache Read Speed: 76,9 Mb/sec

Disk Speed Index: 112

Вобщем у этого результат так себе.

A vi b ne mogli napisat reytingovuyu tablicu na svoye usmotrenie.

Tak obi4nomu useru budet leg4e opredelitsya

AlexV

Цитата:

A vi b ne mogli napisat reytingovuyu tablicu

Так займись этим - ведь в теме уже достаточное количество данных, осталось свести их в единую таблицу результатов!!!

Test environment information

Running under: Windows NT 5.1 Build 2600, Service Pack 1
CPU Type: x86 Family 15 Model 2 Stepping 9, 2405 MHz
Memory: 511 MB (0% free)
Swap: 1250 MB (2% free)

---------------------------------------------------

Drive! 1.0.0 Benchmark Results

Hard Disk: Maxtor 6Y080M0
 Attached to: Adapter
 Using driver: atapi.sys
Size: 78159 MBytes
Geometry:
 Current: 9964 Cylinders, 255 Heads, 63 Sectors
 Default: Unknown

Average Linear Read Speed: 42,5 Mb/sec
Min. Linear Read Speed: 28,5 Mb/sec
Max. Linear Read Speed: 51,5 Mb/sec

Average Access Time: 13,4 ms

Max. Cache Read Speed: 130,7 Mb/sec

Disk Speed Index: 318

---------------------------------------------------

Drive! 1.0.0 Benchmark Results

Hard Disk: SAMSUNG SV1204H
 Attached to: Adapter
 Using driver: atapi.sys
Size: 114494 MBytes
Geometry:
 Current: 14596 Cylinders, 255 Heads, 63 Sectors
 Default: Unknown

Average Linear Read Speed: 31,0 Mb/sec
Min. Linear Read Speed: 19,7 Mb/sec
Max. Linear Read Speed: 39,6 Mb/sec

Average Access Time: 19,8 ms

Max. Cache Read Speed: 92,3 Mb/sec

Disk Speed Index: 157

А вот вам Maxtor ATA133 160Gb 7200rpm 8mb cash сидящий на АТА133 контроллере. F2 почему-то сохранять репорт отказалась, поэтому ввожу вручную

Running under: Windows NT 5.1 Build 2600, Service Pack 1
CPU Type: x86 Family 15 Model 2 Stepping 7, 2539 MHz
Memory: 1023 MB (3% free)
Swap: 1182 MB (2% free)


Attached to: Adapter
Using driver: atapi.sys
Size: 156327 MBytes
Geometry:
Current: 19929 Cylinders, 255 Heads, 63 Sectors
Default: Unknown

Average Linear Read Speed: 46.0 Mb/sec
Min. Linear Read Speed: 27.0 Mb/sec
Max. Linear Read Speed: 64.3 Mb/sec
Average Access Time: 13.7 ms
Max. Cache Read Speed: 144.0 Mb/sec
Disk Speed Index: 337

Сказевые винты отдыхают.


А вот вам Samsung ATA133 160Gb 7200rpm сидящий на этом же АТА133 контроллере.

Attached to: Adapter
Using driver: atapi.sys
Size: 152625 MBytes
Geometry:
Current: 19457 Cylinders, 255 Heads, 63 Sectors
Default: Unknown

Average Linear Read Speed: 36.4 Mb/sec
Min. Linear Read Speed: 17.1 Mb/sec
Max. Linear Read Speed: 51.5 Mb/sec
Average Access Time: 15.0 ms
Max. Cache Read Speed: 108.9 Mb/sec
Disk Speed Index: 243

Угораздило же меня купить это дерьмо! Проэкспериментировал, называется. Лучше бы добавил чирик и взял ещё один Макстор

Running under: Windows NT 5.1 Build 2600, Service Pack 1
CPU Type: x86 Family 15 Model 1 Stepping 3, 1716 MHz
Memory: 255 MB (2% free)
Swap: 618 MB (4% free)

Hard Disk: MAXTOR 6L060J3 (UDMA-133)
Attached to: Adapter
Using driver: atapi.sys
Size: 57255 MBytes
Geometry:
Current: 7299 Cylinders, 255 Heads, 63 Sectors
Default: Unknown

Average Linear Read Speed: 33,1 Mb/sec
Min. Linear Read Speed: 20,5 Mb/sec
Max. Linear Read Speed: 43,0 Mb/sec

Average Access Time: 13,5 ms

Max. Cache Read Speed: 103,4 Mb/sec

Disk Speed Index: 246

Hard Disk: IC35L040AVVA07-0
Attached to: Adapter
Using driver: atapi.sys
Size: 38162 MBytes
Geometry:
Current: 4865 Cylinders, 255 Heads, 63 Sectors
Default: Unknown

Average Linear Read Speed: 36,0 Mb/sec
Min. Linear Read Speed: 17,1 Mb/sec
Max. Linear Read Speed: 46,7 Mb/sec

Average Access Time: 12,2 ms

Max. Cache Read Speed: 103,5 Mb/sec

Disk Speed Index: 295

Running under: Windows NT 5.0 Build 2195, Service Pack 1
CPU Type: x86 Family 15 Model 1 Stepping 3, 1700 MHz
Memory: 511 MB (2% free)
Swap: 1248 MB (2% free)

Hard Disk: IC35L040AVVA07-0
Attached to: Adapter
Using driver: atapi.sys
Size: 39260 MBytes
Geometry:
Current: 5005 Cylinders, 255 Heads, 63 Sectors
Default: Unknown

Average Linear Read Speed: 33,7 Mb/sec
Min. Linear Read Speed: 13,5 Mb/sec
Max. Linear Read Speed: 47,0 Mb/sec

Average Access Time: 14,3 ms

Max. Cache Read Speed: 85,3 Mb/sec

Disk Speed Index: 235

Хм, вроде винт как и у Ton aka hwost а какой разный результат. К сожалению
Ton aka hwost ось не указал.


Добавлено
Вот, сделал повторный тест, закрыв все приложения, (правда не отключал сервисы Win)
результат как говорится на лицо:

Running under: Windows NT 5.0 Build 2195, Service Pack 1
CPU Type: x86 Family 15 Model 1 Stepping 3, 1700 MHz
Memory: 511 MB (4% free)
Swap: 1248 MB (0% free)

Hard Disk: IC35L040AVVA07-0
Attached to: Adapter
Using driver: atapi.sys
Size: 39260 MBytes
Geometry:
Current: 5005 Cylinders, 255 Heads, 63 Sectors
Default: Unknown

Average Linear Read Speed: 34,9 Mb/sec
Min. Linear Read Speed: 13,5 Mb/sec
Max. Linear Read Speed: 46,7 Mb/sec

Average Access Time: 12,3 ms

Max. Cache Read Speed: 67,2 Mb/sec

Disk Speed Index: 285

Из всего этого ИМХО можно сделать вывод, что результаты данного теста являются относительными, так как тесты выполняются при различных условиях, на разных осях не говоря уже о железе.

Test environment information
* Running under: Windows NT 5.0 Build 2195, Service Pack 2
* CPU Type: x86 Family 6 Model 11 Stepping 1, 1096 MHz
* Memory: 158 MB (23% free)
* Swap: 540 MB (2% free)

------------------------------------
Drive! 1.0.0 Benchmark Results
* Hard Disk: Maxtor 6Y040L0
* Attached to: Adapter
* Using driver: IdeChnDr
* Size: 39079 MBytes
* Geometry:
* Current: 4982 Cylinders, 255 Heads, 63 Sectors
* Default: Unknown

* Average Linear Read Speed: 40,3 Mb/sec
* Min. Linear Read Speed: 28,6 Mb/sec
* Max. Linear Read Speed: 51,5 Mb/sec

* Average Access Time: 13,4 ms
* Max. Cache Read Speed: 87,8 Mb/sec

* Disk Speed Index: 301

────────────────────────▌Test environment information▐────────────────────────

■ Running under: Windows NT 5.1 Build 2600,
■ CPU Type: x86 Family 15 Model 1 Stepping 2, 1607 MHz
■ Memory: 511 MB (1% free)
■ Swap: 1250 MB (1% free)

───────────────────────▌Drive! 1.0.0 Benchmark Results▐───────────────────────

■ Hard Disk: IC35L040AVVA07-0
 Attached to: Adapter
 Using driver: IdeChnDr.sys
■ Size: 39260 MBytes
■ Geometry:
 Current: 5005 Cylinders, 255 Heads, 63 Sectors
 Default: Unknown

■ Average Linear Read Speed: 35,1 Mb/sec
■ Min. Linear Read Speed: 19,8 Mb/sec
■ Max. Linear Read Speed: 47,0 Mb/sec

■ Average Access Time: 12,6 ms

■ Max. Cache Read Speed: 102,4 Mb/sec

■ Disk Speed Index: 278

Что-то я совсем не понемаю, у меня эта прога в мегабайтах(MB) показывает а вы все в мегабитах(Mb) пишите.


General
Running under: WinNT 5.1 Build 2600, Service Pack 1
CPU: x86 Family 15 Model 0 Stepping 10, 1600MHz
Memory: 511 MB (1% free)
Swap: 1248 MB (0% free)
-------------------------------------------------------------

Controller
Device driver: atapi
Interrupt: 0
IO Address: 0000h
DMA: Enabled
-------------------------------------------------------------

Disk
Size: 39087 MBytes
Current Geometry: 4983 Cylinders, 255 Heads, 63 Sectors
-------------------------------------------------------------

Benchmark
FUJITSU MPG3409AT E

Average Linear Read Speed: 21.6 MB/s
Min. Linear Read Speed: 7.9 MB/s
Max. Linear Read Speed: 30.3 MB/s
Average Access Time: 16.2 ms
Max cache Read speed: 79.1 MB/s
Disk speed index: 134

Цитата:

MAXTOR

быстрый и надежный ,а за ним Seagate

Цитата:

К сожалению
Ton aka hwost ось не указал.

Комп рабочий IBM NetVista на PIV 1.6 ось ХР Pro без сервиспаков...